Large circular saws, also known as beam saws, cater to professionals working with hefty materials like timber framing, butchering slabs, and glue-laminated beams. With a blade diameter exceeding 16 inches, these saws can rip through thick lumber in a single pass, saving time and effort on demanding projects. However, their size and power make them less suitable for everyday DIY tasks.
There are two main contenders in the 16-5/16 circular saw market: the SkilSaw Super Sawsquatch and the Makita 5402NA. Both offer similar cutting capacities (around 6 inches at 90 degrees) and are powered by robust 15-amp motors. Here’s a closer look at their strengths and weaknesses:
- SkilSaw Super Sawsquatch:
Worm Drive Advantage: The worm drive design provides superior torque for handling tough cuts in hardwoods and wet lumber.
- Magnesium Housing: This construction keeps the weight manageable compared to traditional aluminum bodies.
- Repositionable Handle: Enhances comfort and control for different cutting positions.
- Limited Dust Port Options: While a dust port is included, users might require additional attachments for better dust collection.
- Makita 5402NA:
Direct Drive Simplicity: The direct drive motor offers a potentially lower maintenance requirement compared to worm drives.
- Lower Noise Level: Makita boasts quieter operation, making it a consideration for noise-restricted workplaces.
- Ergonomic Features: An oversized trigger handle and large depth control lever improve user comfort during extended use.
- Limited Bevel Capacity: The bevel range might be slightly less than the SkilSaw for specific angled cuts.
- Choosing the Right Saw:
The ideal choice boils down to project needs and user preferences. For those prioritizing raw power and handling in challenging materials, the SkilSaw Super Sawsquatch might be the better option. Conversely, if noise reduction and potentially easier maintenance are crucial factors, the Makita 5402NA could be a better fit.
- Conclusion:
16-5/16 circular saws are formidable tools for heavy-duty cutting applications. Carefully evaluating the strengths and weaknesses of the SkilSaw Super Sawsquatch and the Makita 5402NA will ensure you select the right saw to conquer your large-timber projects efficiently. Remember, these saws are specialty tools and may not be necessary for everyday woodworking tasks.
